Potato Chip vs Old Fashioned Hair Claw: Which Wins?
By Jenny Lemons: Fun, Creatively Designed Accessories | Published: 2026-10-25
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Large Potato Chip Bag Hair Claw Clip and the Large Old Fashioned Hair Claw Clip. Find out which playful accessory fits your style and hair needs.
Quick answer
Choose the Large Potato Chip Bag Hair Claw if you want a sturdy, oversized clip with a playful snack look. Pick the Large Old Fashioned Hair Claw if you prefer a vintage cocktail-inspired design with hand-painted details.
Design and Material Differences
Both clips are made from cellulose acetate, a plant-based alternative to plastic, so they are eco-friendly and durable. The Potato Chip Bag design features a bright blue bag with wavy white details and ridged chips, creating a bold, snack-inspired statement. The Old Fashioned clip is hand-painted with a cherry and orange slice, giving it a vintage cocktail charm that is more subtle and elegant.
The Potato Chip clip is described as a large claw that offers a sturdy hold for sweeping up more hair. The Old Fashioned clip measures 4" x 3.5" and is also designed for holding hair in place. Both are large, but the Potato Chip may feel bulkier due to its sculpted chip details.
Hold and Practicality
If you have thick or long hair, the Potato Chip Bag claw's larger size and sturdy hold are ideal for securing a bun or half-up style. The Old Fashioned clip, while still large, is better suited for medium to thick hair and adds a pop of charm without being overly bulky.
Both clips are handmade and unique, so slight variations in color and detail are normal. This makes each piece one of a kind but also means the fit may vary slightly.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Potato Chip Bag: Bold & Sturdy: Best for thick or long hair that needs a strong hold. The playful snack design makes a loud statement, but the sculpted chips may feel bulkier on smaller heads. Ideal for those who want a fun, oversized clip that actually holds their hair.
- Old Fashioned: Vintage & Versatile: Hand-painted with cocktail details, this clip offers a more refined novelty look. It fits medium to thick hair well, but may not hold very thick hair as securely as the Potato Chip. Great for adding charm without overwhelming your outfit.
- Material & Eco-Friendly: Both are made from cellulose acetate, a plant-based plastic alternative, so they are more sustainable than standard plastic clips.
Product facts at a glance
- Large Potato Chip Bag Hair Claw Clip: Large Potato Chip Bag Hair Claw Clip: made from cellulose acetate, features a bright blue bag with wavy white details and ridged chips, offers a sturdy hold for sweeping up more hair. The sculpted design and larger size provide a secure grip for thick or long hair, making it a practical choice for all-day wear.
Large Potato Chip Bag Hair Claw Clip - Large Old Fashioned Hair Claw Clip: Large Old Fashioned Hair Claw Clip: handmade and hand-painted from durable cellulose acetate, measures 4" x 3.5", features a cherry and orange slice for a vintage twist. The hand-painted details add a unique, artistic touch, and the size is versatile for medium to thick hair without being too heavy.
Large Old Fashioned Hair Claw Clip
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Anyone with thick or long hair who wants a sturdy, oversized clip with a playful snack design
- Those who love bold, conversation-starting accessories
Not for
- People with fine or short hair who may find the Potato Chip clip too large or heavy
- Those who prefer a more subtle, vintage-inspired look without the snack theme
